I'm a Good Debater - And This is My Strategy
How do I become a good debater?

This article is a featured community post from our subreddit


Summary: 

It's highly possible that you're a poor debater. Don't sweat it as I was too until I changed my strategy.


Body: 

If you're like me you enjoy a good debate then it's actually worth taking a moment to take a hard look at yourself and how you actually debate with others. I'll just dive right into a car metaphor to make a point here - Please consider this entire write-up as your moment to give yourself a maintenance check and fix any faults you may discover. (Along with some potential upgrades) It'll be tough to look at yourself objectively - but if you're to grow as a person and improve your communication skills then this is essential dude.

Human bias has a tendency to make it seem like you're Julius fucking Caesar during heated debates from time to time when you're more than likely comparable to Wayne Rooney during a post-game press conference.

My eureka moment of discovering I sucked at debating was at the start of this year at a friend's house party. I got into a heated debate with a girl (Subject not important) while my buddy decided it was a good idea to film on his phone a few minutes of our word battle before he lost interest. Fast forward to the end of the night during the taxi drive home:

Wanna see the footage of your argument tonight dude?

Oh yeah! of course I did. My buddy showed me the 2 minutes of a cringe worthy performance which stuck with me as I tried to sleep that night. So what did I discover?

  • I have an ego - Yeah, at a certain point of the debate it was clear that my ego was pushing for total victory and in no case was I looking to reach the truth or understand why she thought the way she did.
  • I speak very quickly - There is something about the pace of the debate which favours a controlled projection. When speaking quickly, it's easy to muddle words and it can come across to others that you're losing your cool.
  • I interrupt frequently - It was clear at certain times during the debate when I knew she was wrong and I would continuously interrupt her - like a man possessed I couldn't wait to crush her! (Figuratively of course) This done nothing but create frustration and damage my respect to observers.

The Fix:

Ironically it was my ego that couldn't accept that I sucked at this - so I immediatly got to work to look for a fix. (I guess the ego works for some things right?)

This TED talk was the first video I came across online and oh boy, did it change everything. Easily my best TED talk ever! Simply because it kicked my ass and told me what I needed to hear.

  • Step 1: watch the TED talk above (9min)
  • Step 2: Redefine the perimeters of winning - If you watched the video above, then you know what this means. Accept that the end goal of the debate is truth - your fellow debater is an ally who can help you get to this location.

Who actually wins in an argument? In a conventional debate:

The loser = Gains a new perspective and moves forward stronger
The winner = No change (Ego gets a tap on the back)

  • Step 3: Pace adjustment - With my ego eliminated from the equation, I immediatly noticed my conversational pace maintained a gentle flow throughout the discussions that followed. Who would have guessed? When you're not fighting for bragging rights, your speech tends to slow down a notch.
     
  • Step 4: Dance the Dance - Now when I'm debating with the aforementioned changes in effect, it feels that I'm flowing through debates in a smug-like fashion as I'm untouchable. I dance through the debate happy to embrace defeat if it takes me to the truth. I hurl praise at my opponents as they make smart comments to their utter surprise - but at a moments notice I swing the opposite way and call them out for inaccuracies. A dance is how I describe it - debates are no longer tense for me, and this calmness now renders most of my opponents into a frustration.

Conclusion:

I look back at that recent moment during the party with a smug sense of satisfaction. I've self-diagnosed my shitty debate style and turned myself into a good debater in a very short period of time. This is a skill that follows us throughout life and directly effects our relationships and our ability to communicate with others. An interesting bi-product of my new approach however is the clarity in which I can now see others struggling as they debate with me. They're people of the old way - fighting to achieve victory at all costs. So, put down your sword and join me in the ranks of intelligent debaters. Hoorah!

This article is a featured community post from our subreddit. We periodically feature the best ideas and life lessons provided directly from you, the reader. Share your insightful concepts on our community subreddit and perhaps your lesson will change somebody's life. Each and every one of us can dig deep and contribute wisdom to help others, so don't hesitate to share your ideas today.